From: R. Wilder
Re: Bro Crim OSCA Speciale – History updated
Date: April 19, 2008
Recent History (2007-2008).
I spoke in October 2007 to Marty Naughton of Nyack, NY. Marty is
a close friend of Pete Fatta from whom I purchased the OSCA Speciale in
October. Marty previously worked for 180 Sports ? Classics,
located at 180 West Broadway in New York City. 180 Sports ? Classics was
owned by Ross Provenzano who died in 2005. Ross’s son, Ross Jr., is not
involved in the business and I don’t know if the business still exists.
1980-1982 to 2007:
In the early 1980’s, Ross Provenzano employed two guys, Steve Bucelato
and Ali Luggo, whose job it was to uncover and assist in the restoration
of old, exotic “barn finds” to purchase for restoration and/or resale.
Ali Luggo was a former race car driver. Apparently Steve Bucelato
found this car around 1983 on a lead from Rocky Santiago in Oklahoma, purchased
it and brought it to New York City to 180 Sports ? Classics. According
to R. David Brown, sports race car driver and former President of SCCA
for 8 years, he believes the car ended up in the race shop of Bill Strange
(see below).in Ft. Worth Texas about this time and believes that Bucelato
may have purchased the car from Strange.
According to Marty Naughton, Ali Lugo was going to perform the mechanical
elements of the restoration; however as the project languished, the chassis
and body work was transferred to Greg Bailey in Hamden MA. Apparently Greg
Bailey did some cut chars and other specialty body work for Chinetti. Ali
Lugo has since died. Over a period of 8-10 years, Greg Bailey did some
body work on the car making new floor and inner panels and modifying the
rear quarter panels to accept rear tail lights that subsequently have been
removed as the rear tail light housings were definitely incorrect and made
for tail lights that came with the car in 2007 and were also incorrect.
According to Gregg Bailey, he has had the car since around 1993 in his
shop. Greg remembers the rear quarter panels as needing the most work.
Apparently the car’s rear quarters were widened as the car was converted
into a dragster in the 1960’s or 1970’s and had a Chevy engine and an American
rear end and rear tires. According to Greg he did no work on the frame
and the front from the rear of the doors forward remained the came. Gregg
made a new aluminum skin for the hood with louvers and we are reskinning
the hood as the original car did not have any hood louvers.
Pre- 1983 U.S. History:
I sent an email to Victor Flood per a recommendation of Harold Pace.
Victor is a long time car guy from the Dallas – Ft. Worth area and is an
author or co-author of automotive racing books and a free lance writer
for many years for many auto publications. . Victor went to see the car
with Harold Pace around 1972-1974. The car was owned at that time by J.
Paul DuToit who was a friend of Victor’s father. At that time, the car
was a faded red rolling chassis. It had no floor boards, engine, wiring
harness, gauges, etc. It had Borannis on the front and what Victor remembers
as American wheels on the rear. Victor did not remember anything distinctive
about the rear end or drive train. Apparently, according to Harold
(or maybe Victor), J. Paul DuToit bought the car in response to an ad in
the Ft. worth Star Telegram advertising a auto trailer hitch for $75. .
When DuToit went to see the trailer hitch, he asked the seller how much
for the car that was attached to it. The seller said “if you give me $75
bucks you can have the car too”. DuToit took both.
Victor believes the car was sold shortly after he saw the car but
he did not know to whom. Harold Pace believes the car ended up directly
(or indirectly) a few years later at Bill Strange’s shop in Ft. Worth.
Bill Strange was an investment “deals guy” whop put other people’s money
in various investments including oil and real estate. Apparently, some
of the investors’ money found its way into Strange’s auto racing shop in
Ft. Worth where he sponsored a Can Am racing team and bought and sold exotic
cars (mainly Ferraris). In the early–mid 1980s, Strange filed bankruptcy
and apparently spent some time in jail. It is at this time (1983 +/-) it
is believed that Steve Bucelato bought the car from Strange and brought
it back to New York.
At some point, Bucelato (or Ali Luggo) also purchased some spare
parts as the car was basically a rolling chassis (at best) in 1983. These
parts included an early 1959 OSCA Fiat engine and transmission which were
rebuilt (remachined with new sleeves and pistons, new rods and remachined
crank) but never reassembled. Also purchased were some side draft Weber
DCOE 40’s and other engine parts for the OSCA Fiat 1500 cc over head twin
cam. In the engine rebuild someone drilled and inserted 4 brass fittings
and brass oil lines along the center of the head between the twin cam covers
in order to more closely replicate the original OSCA 1100 cc engine.
1954-1956- The Bro Crim OSCA Special US History Years:
When Bro Crim returned from Italy to Ft. Worth, Texas in late 1954
he managed his father’s movie theater business and later became the owner
of the Cowtown Drive-In. According to Liggett Crim Jr., Bro’s son, 57 years
old and now living in Texas, he has a very limited recollection of the
car and where it was raced. According to Liggett, his father had several
race cars and raced in regional Texas events and specifically at Eagle
Mountain. He remembers the car being white with blue stripes and that his
father, Bro, had a mid 50s mercury station wagon, also white with blue
stripes, which he used to tow the car to various regional races. As his
mother and father were divorced when Crim returned to the U.S., he did
not spend full time with his father. Nell Crim remembers that Bro was very
frustrated with the car as it never finished a race, she believes. “Something
was always going wrong or blowing up” she recently remarked. After a few
races, Bro was disgusted with the car and sold it but she is not sure to
whom or exactly when but she is guessing it was within 1- 1.5 years after
returning from Italy.
The best recollections of the car and its racing history when Crim
moved to Ft. Worth were from R. David Jones, who at age 15-17, worked at
Bill Parm’s racing shop ion Ft. Worth. For those of you who are not familiar
with David Jones, he became infatuated with race cars in high school an
infatuation he maintained for the past 50 years as a driver and president
of SCCA for 8 years. David Jones remembers the car at Parm’s race shop
where it was looked after and prepared for racing. He also remembers Crim
and Parm being good friends. According to David Jones, in a race in 1956-57,
the engine seized, either it blew a rod or broke a crank, after which the
engine and Siata 4 speed transmission were removed. The removal was done
by 3 individuals, Larry Johnson, Harold Hartman, and a 3rd man (name
not remembered).David said these 3 guys also raced and worked on Healey
100s and David recollects that they may have put in a Healey engine and
transmission but he can’t be certain. While the engine was repairable,
as an OSCA engine, parts were scarce and the 3rd unnamed mechanic was going
to do the repairs. Shortly thereafter the unnamed individual moved to out
of the area. David remembers for many moths thereafter (possibly for more
than a year) this individual would call every 3 months to ask a question
of Parm or one of Parm’s senior mechanics. David’s belief from those calls
is that the engine was not getting rebuilt and this guy was having problems.
At this point nobody knows the name of this 3rd individual and attempts
to track down either Hartman or Johnson through the military records bureaus
,( both were at the Waco Air National Guard Unit or in the Air Force
stationed at Waco at the time) have been unsuccessful.
Other race car guys from Texas have been unable to help and Burdett Martin,
former race car driver from Ft. Worth who subsequently moved to Chicago
many years ago has not been able to help locate the engine or transmission.
The Maserati Brothers sons, who keep extensive and updated records of all
the OSCA engines and OSCA cars made by their fathers, show engine #1111
as missing with location unknown.
The only other U.S. racing history of the Bro Crim OSCA Special was
from an email received recently from Pete Veck who runs an on line Italian
car “magazine”, VeloceToday. Pete emailed me that Jim Sitz (not sure
who he is) has a record of Crim driving 1700 miles to a racing event in
Dodge City, KS on August 19, 1956; however he (and we) can find no
entry forms or results of this race as it relates to the Crim OSCA Special.
Comirato- Gilco OSCA Special- The Early Years:
The original chassis was constructed by Gilco (Gilberto Colombo)
who constructed virtually all the chassis for Enzo Ferrari from 1947-1957.
The chassis number 5504549 is stamped on two places on the main tubular
chassis rails. From photos, we believe that the chassis is a Gilco 203
chassis; however, I received a recent email from a Gilco aficionado in
Italy , who believes it is a Gilco chassis 200 series but not necessarily
a 203. He needs actual measurement of all tubes and overall length to confirm.
It appears, from research done buy John DeBoer, that the original chassis
was built for Alberto Comirato, a well known and successful race car driver
(along with his wife who was also a famous race car driver) both immediately
before and after the war. Comirato also was a well respected mechanic and
was at the leading edge of the race car “technology” of the time. As Comirato
owned several race cars, there is no certainty that pictures of cars
we have found showing Comirato in races were actually this Crim OSCA special.
Having said that, piecing together the history is as follows:
1. Comirato constructed his own car in 1949 using the Gilco chassis
(chassis # 5504549) , a Fiat 1100S engine and a cycled fender car body
typical of the years immediately following the war. There are race records
referring to this car as a Comirato-Fiat -Gilco and the pictures show the
exhaust pipe on the passenger’s (right ) side of the car.
2. In 1950, Comirato purchased from the Maserati Brothers, OSCA MT4
engine #1111, an 1100 cc twin cam engine replacing the Fiat 1100S engine.
There are pictures of this car racing showing the exhaust manifold on the
drivers (left) side which is the correct side for exhausting an OSCA engine.
The car at that time was referred to as a Comirato-OSCA- Gilco car in various
race programs and race result sheets.
3. Research by John DeBoer, based on information from the Milan Automobile
Registry from a photo of the Milan license plate and the chassis
number confirmed that Comirato was in fact the owner of the car with
the Gilco chassis number stamped on my car.
4. In 1954, a wealthy Texan, Bro Crim, whose family owned land in
Kilgore
Texas with one of the largest oil finds in east Texas history (1930)
, went to Italy with his 5 year old son, Liggett and wife, to learn to
drive on European race courses and purchased a race car when he arrived
in Italy. While the articles of the time written by Hans Tanner lead the
reader to believe that Crim had the car custom built to his specifications,
it appears that was not the case. Sometime around 1953-54, the car changed
hands, possibly more than once, and was ultimately rebodied using the original
Gilco Chassis with a more modern design (i.e. no cycle fenders), looking
much like a smaller version of the period Ferrari race cars. The aluminum
body was made by the Palazzi Brothers (who reportedly made bodies for Ferrari)
and the car was reassembled by Crepaldi and sold to Crim. It is unclear
whether Crim knew he was purchasing a rebodied race car of Alberto Comirato.
1. While in Texas, Crim made contact with Hans Tanner who, among
other things, acted as Crim’s purchasing agent for the car. According to
Nell Becker, formerly Nell Crim, Bro’s first wife who is still alive and
remarkably active with a great sense of humor.
2. While Crim owned a 1950 Jaguar (not sure what model), Crim learned
to race in Italy in this newly acquired car. When he arrived in Italy (with
the Mercury station wagon also painted white with blue stripes, the OSCA
was not fully prepared and he had to wait. This was frustrating to Crim
as he had hoped to participate in the Italian circuit races in 1955. According
to Nell, when Bro finally got the car, it the first day at the track, on
a rain soaked surface he spun the car and did some damage. According to
Nell, the car was repaired but never raced in Italy. This is somewhat contrary
to the information in an Article by Tanner and a picture of the car on
a track in Italy in one of the Italian Racing History books. .
Crim did enjoy the camaraderie of other European and US race car
drivers at the time and was in it more for the experience than anything
else. His son remembers living in a house and his father invited over the
race car drivers of the day. He believes he met Maston Gregory and a famous
German driver whose name he could not remember. Nell also remembers
Phil Hill and trips to the grand prix in Portugal (?) and to Le Mans. After
the 1955 racing season, in Italy, Crim returned to Ft. Worth with
the Bro Crim OSCA Special (and the white and blue Mercury tow car)
and the sections of this memo above pick up the story from there. Steve
Bucelato believes he has a picture of the car in Texas with Carroll Shelby
standing or sitting next to the car and next to Bro Crim.
Bucelato also believes the car was blue with white stripes; however
there is no evidence of those colors used on the car. He also believes
that Shelby campaigned the car. Bucelato has a friend who is close to Shelby
and is going to try to see if Shelby remembers the car or driving the car.
Shelby and Crim were about the same age and both came from East Texas,
albeit from very different economic backgrounds. It is believed they were
friends but we are not sure how much contact they had with each other.
Nell Crim remembers going to events with Carroll Shelby and his wife so
the relationship was more than just acquaintances.
Next: Bro Crim's
OSCA -- Restoration Photos
Back to: Bro Crim's
OSCA -- Homepage
|